The Hooch Life Guide to American Whiskey
There are thousands of variables, mixes and matches that go into a distiller's formulation for the perfect whiskey. But it all starts with grain. High alcohol yielding corn, with a subtle, sweet spice and earthiness due to its husk. The smooth, mellow, honey-like sweetness of wheat. The complexity of rye, accenting other grains by bringing out fruit and spice. Malted barley, with its beautifully sweet and creamy feel and depth.
From there, even within a single type of whiskey, there's a world of possibilities. The depth of char on the American oak barrels directly influences color and flavor, and staves (toasted oak chips) can produce a mellow sweetness. But in the end, it's time in the barrel that contributes up to 50-70% of the whiskey's flavor. To be classified a straight whiskey, two years in the barrel is required, although four is the norm. Maturation creates depth and introduces flavors like vanilla, caramel, honey, and spice.
Thank you so much, Robert Sickler, Master of Whisky from Diageo, and Todd Leopold of Leopold Bros. for your many, many contributions to this piece. Together, we've created a guide through the main types of American whiskey. Here's your chance to understand the differences, appreciate the flavors, create a shopping list, and drink your way through a true American art form.
BOURBON WHISKEY
The big dog, caramel, vanilla, toffee and a nice earthy spice.
This is America's national spirit, and an icon of flavor on its own or in a cocktail. Aged in new charred oak barrels, its mash bill (recipe) consists of at least 51% corn, resulting in a full-bodied, sweet and spicy character. Temperance, Prohibition and a couple World Wars took its toll on the national whiskey industry, but American producers have now spent decades restoring bourbon's great tradition and international reputation.
Our Recommendations
1792 Ridgemont Reserve Kentucky Bourbon
1792 Ridgemont Reserve the Official Toasting Bourbon of the Kentucky Bourbon Festival. It's the real deal.
Bardstown, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Angel's Envy Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
No wonder master distiller Lincoln Henderson personally samples every batch of Angels Envy. It's too good to resist.
Louisville, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Blanton's Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey
A delicious bourbon once reserved for dignitaries and politicians, each barrel of Blanton's is slightly different.
Frankfort, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Breckenridge Bourbon Whiskey
A high altitude bourbon with a spicy cinnamon, tongue-tingling flavor. It's great out of a flask or in a cocktail.
Breckenridge, CO
Moderate - $20-$50
Buffalo Trace Bourbon
From one of America's oldest distilleries, this is a great introductory bourbon because of its exceptional quality.
Frankfort, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Bulleit Frontier Bourbon Whiskey
Bulleit is an excellent go-to bourbon for everyday mixing of a variety of whiskey cocktails.
Lawrenceburg, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Eagle Rare Straight Bourbon Whiskey
This hooch has a serious pedigree and should be a mainstay in your home bar. It makes a divine Mint Julep.
Franklin, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Four Roses 2011 Limited Edition Single Barrel Bourbon
For what may be the best Old Fashioned of your life, use this straight-from-the-barrel bourbon.
Lawrenceburg, KY
Premium - $50-$100
Maker's 46
By adding seared French oak to the aging bourbon, Makers Mark adds new layers of spice and oak.
Loretto, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
McKenzie Bourbon Whiskey
A smooth, buttery bourbon that tastes like a Heath bar in a glass with toffee and vanilla flavors.
Burdett, NY
Moderate - $20-$50
Michter's US*1 Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey
It tastes likes like honeycomb minus the sweetness and leaves your tongue tingling with spice.
Bardstown, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Hooch Bartender-recommended Cocktails
The rich sweet and spice of bourbon blends beautifully with the bitter Campari and full-bodied sweet vermouth. This "man about town" cocktail dances delightfully between an Italian Negroni and an American Manhattan.
Bourbon has a playful way about it. The Whiskey Smash highlights the refreshing side of bourbon and whatever fruits make their way into the cocktail.
TENNESSEE WHISKEY
Bourbon's first cousin, with a sweeter, smoother, and smoky charcoal finish.
Like Bourbon, Tennessee whiskey is at least 51% corn and aged in new charred oak barrels. But to be called Tennessee whiskey, it has to be made in the state and although not federally mandated, they also typically go through what is called the Lincoln Country Process—filtered through locally procured, sugar maple charcoal, before barrel aging.
Our Recommendations
Cascade Hollow Tennessee Whiskey
This is one fine bottle of hooch with a rich, smooth flavor that may become your new go-to whiskey.
Tullahoma, TN
Budget - under $20
Benjamin Prichard's Tennessee Whiskey
This perfectly aged whiskey celebrates the Prichard family's pre-Prohibition distilling secrets.
Kelso, TN
Moderate - $20-$50
Hooch Bartender-recommended Cocktails
The sweet and smooth Tennessee favorite is a welcomed partner in this winter warmer-upper. Cloves and lemon are an especially nice accent flavor to the smoked, sweet notes.
Any sour needs a touch of sweet to balance it out. A simple and refreshing classic with fresh lemon juice, simple syrup and Tennessee whiskey does the trick.
RYE WHISKEY
A little leaner but assertive. Bitter with spicy pepper and hints of dried fruit. Think rye bread.
As America's original aged whiskey, rye was most likely the base spirit in many of the classic whiskey cocktails. As the classics have again become the "latest" trend, more and more distillers are making high quality rye—defined as at least 51% rye and aged in new charred oak.
Our Recommendations
Bulleit Rye Whiskey
Bulleit Rye Whiskey tastes like how you would imagine Don Draper smells: hints of sweet, spicy tobacco.
Lawrenceburg, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
High West Whiskey Double Rye
An untamed young whiskey is blended with a sweet, smooth aged whiskey to create perfect harmony in a glass.
Park City, UT
Moderate - $20-$50
Old Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey
This is a great choice for rye novices and a Mad Men favorite. It's also a great value option.
Clermont, KY
Budget - under $20
Redemption Rye Whiskey
Redemption Rye Whiskey isn't afraid to push its rye to the limit. At 95% rye, it's one feisty bottle of hooch.
Bardstown, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
(ri)1 Rye Whiskey
Perfect rye for tentative bourbon fans not yet prepared to take the full plunge into spicier rye whiskeys.
Clermont, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Rittenhouse Rye Whiskey
Great for all whiskey drinkers looking for a delicious whiskey carrying a little extra punch.
Bardstown, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Sazerac Rye 18-Year-Old Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
Part of the fun of tasting an older whiskey is picking out all of the flavor that has accumulated over time.
Frankfort, KY
Luxury - over $100
Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey
This is a good, clean rye whiskey with big flavors, a little vanilla and the rye punch you're looking for.
Frankfort, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Templeton Rye Whiskey
Al Capone's whiskey of choice was Templeton. Made with only the best rye, this whiskey is still a speakeasy favorite.
Templeton, IA
Moderate - $20-$50
Whistle Pig Straight Rye
You don't have to be a connoisseur to appreciate this whiskey's subtle nuances. It's just damn good.
Shoreham, VT
Premium - $50-$100
Hooch Bartender-recommended Cocktails
Silky, spicy and seductive. Nothing compares to the Vieux Carré's finesse of French sophistication with American swagger.
It's the holiest of American cocktails, made with a sinfully spicy rye whiskey, an absinthe rinse, sugar and Pechaud's bitters. Geeky, maybe. Complex, definitely. But finding a good one to sink into is always well worth the effort.
CORN WHISKEY
Bourbon's crazy little brother, with a bad reputation that belies its sweet, spicy, earthy soul.
Moonshine, white dog, white lightning, corn squeezin's they're all high-proof corn whiskies. Another precursor to bourbon, many were made with sugar, aged in Mason jars and made for legal trade, before going underground for illegal production and sale. Today, corn whiskies are at least 80% corn and aged in un-charred or previously used oak barrels, if it's aged at all. So corn whiskey often lacks the deep oaky flavor and color of other whiskies. Many are high in alcohol content, contain sugar, and are sometimes infused with fun and interesting flavors.
Our Recommendations
Balcones Baby Blue Whiskey
The first legal whiskey from Texas, this smooth blue corn whiskey has an unusually nutty flavor.
Waco, TX
Premium - $50-$100
Buffalo Trace White Dog Mash #1
At 125 proof, this hooch will put some hair on your chest. It is actually drinkable neat, and makes for one stiff cocktail
City, State
Moderate - $20-$50
Glen Thunder Corn Whiskey
This is a perfect introduction to un-aged whiskey, or "white dog," and leaves a nice warm tingle on your tongue.
Burdett, NY
Budget - under $20
Hudson New York Corn Whiskey
Smoother than most un-aged whiskeys, Hudson Corn Whiskey has a fresh flavor with hints of the tropics.
Gardiner, NY
Moderate - $20-$50
Ole Smoky Apple Pie Moonshine
The first legal moonshine in the United States, Ole Smoky goes down smooth like warm apple pie.
Gatlinburg, TN
Moderate - $20-$50
XXX Shine
XXX Shine has a sweet corn flavor and is lower proof than most moonshine, making this a sip-able, mix-able hooch.
Philadelphia, PA
Moderate - $20-$50
Hooch Bartender-recommended Cocktails
Bold, raw and beautiful. Only white whiskies need apply. The flavors of the whiskey are accentuated by the lightly flavored, but full body of Lillet Blanc, and the hint of orange bitters.
You may want to hold back on the sugar depending on the type of corn whiskey. But the youngest Old Fashioned can be quite the treat when poured right.
MALT WHISKEY
Deep and complex, with a creamy, malt cereal or cookie sweetness.
Single malt Scotch must be made from a single distillery and from a single grain: barley. The Scotch single malt industry is well known, highly regulated and respected, but the American version is becoming quite the trend. American malt whiskey must be made from 51% malted barley. Distillers can also use peat (like many Scotches do) or other smoking techniques in the process, resulting in a charred or smoky flavor.
Our Recommendations
Corsair Triple Smoke Single Malt Whiskey
Inspired by the smokey Scotch whiskies, this American hooch has a smoky sweet balance, tempting you to take another sip.
Bowling Green, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
DownSlope Distilling Double-Diamond Whiskey
This fruity, young whiskey is about as close as you can get to an Irish whiskey without actually being Irish.
Centennial, CO
Moderate - $20-$50
Prichard's Single Malt Whiskey
Half Irish whiskey, half Tennessee whiskey, this is a truly fine American spirit that would please the Celts.
Kelso, TN
Moderate - $20-$50
Hooch Bartender-recommended Cocktails
Give this fine piece of work its due. Nothing tastes better than American malt whiskey with the Rob Royal treatment—simple and lush, showcasing a beautifully crafted whiskey.
A nice, long sip of whiskey ginger. There's almost no better combination in the world. A bold malt whiskey stands up to the dry ginger, accented just right by a piece of lemon.
WHEAT WHISKEY
The unusual prodigy of the family, soft and smooth, with a honey-like roundness.
American distillers have a habit of striking off into unexpected directions. So while wheat has been minimally incorporated into mash bills before, few whiskies have used it as the primary grain (at least 51%, aged in new charred oak barrels). Like all prodigies, wheat whiskies shine with American independence and a delicious mellow taste that lands somewhere in between a sweet bourbon and a spicy rye.
Our Recommendations
Bernheim Straight Wheat Whiskey
Bernheim is the original American wheat whiskey. It has a delicate, nutty flavor that's very drinkable.
Louisville, KY
Moderate - $20-$50
Breuckelen Whiskey
Breuckelen is aged, fermented, distilled, barreled, matured and bottled right in Brooklyn, NY.
Brooklyn, NY
Moderate - $20-$50
Dry Fly Washington Wheat Whiskey
Washington Wheat Whiskey is a youthful drinkable whiskey that exemplifies craft distilling at it's finest.
Spokane, WA
Premium - $50-$100
RoughStock Spring Wheat Whiskey
A delicate whiskey perfect for sipping neat while watching the sun set in a big Montana sky.
Bozeman, MT
Moderate - $20-$50
Hooch Bartender-recommended Cocktails
It's silky smooth and honey-like for your sweet loving side, but also a strong and honest way to showcase a great wheat whiskey.
Perfect for someone who likes whiskey, but doesn't know it yet. The texture, accent flavors and sip-ability will win over the toughest critic.

